Abstract
In 2026, the Finnish Education Evaluation Centre (FINEEC) carried out an evaluation of the Vocational Qualification, Further Vocational Qualification and Specialist Vocational Qualification in Agriculture. The evaluation involved examining the pedagogical activities of vocational education and training (VET) providers offering these qualifications, the competence of students and the extent to which these qualifications prepare students for working life and further studies. The evaluation encompassed 27 VET providers offering the Vocational Qualification in Agriculture, 14 VET providers offering the Further Vocational Qualification in Agriculture and 4 VET providers offering the Specialist Vocational Qualification in Agriculture. The evaluation is part of the national evaluation of learning outcomes in VET and is based on a plan drawn up jointly by FINEEC, the Ministry of Education and Culture and the Finnish National Agency for Education on vocational qualifications to be evaluated in 2021–2026.
The evaluation was based on a wide range of data. Data on the pedagogical activities of the VET providers was collected through self-evaluations carried out in collaboration with employers. Pedagogical activities were also evaluated on the basis of the results of national VET student and working life feedback surveys as well as information obtained from the KOSKI database. The competence of students was evaluated on the basis of grades awarded for competence demonstrations and common qualification units as well as assessments carried out by the VET providers and employer representatives. Data on students’ experiences was obtained from the Amisbarometri VET student survey and survey of VET graduates. The effectiveness of the provided VET was also evaluated with the help of data available in the Finnish National Agency for Education's statistics service Vipunen on VET completion and employment after graduation, among other things.
Based on the experiences of the VET providers and students, the personalisation of studies is, for the most part, well-realised in the vocational qualifications in agriculture. Key aspects of the personal competence development plan process, such as the identification and recognition of previously acquired competence, planning for the acquisition of missing competence, the updating of personal competence development plans and the possibility of progressing through studies at one’s own pace, are well-realised for the most part. However, among some VET providers offering the vocational qualification and further vocational qualification, students’ freedom of choice as regards their studies, as well as the monitoring, evaluation and development of the personal competence development plan process, are less well-realised than other aspects.
The implementation of workplace competence demonstrations and the participation of employer representatives in their assessment are fairly well-realised in the vocational qualifications in agriculture. The share of competence demonstrations organised at workplaces was 62% for the initial vocational qualification and 86–89% for the further vocational qualification and specialist vocational qualification. The vast majority of competence demonstrations were assessed jointly by a teacher and an employer representative: the share of competence demonstrations assessed this way was 72% for the initial vocational qualification, 88% for the further vocational qualification and 98% for the specialist vocational qualification. The most common reasons given for organising competence demonstrations at educational institutions were the students’ need for special support, their lack of transferable skills and the limited availability of workplaces or their unsuitability for competence demonstrations.
Based on grades awarded for competence demonstrations and common units, the average level of competence of students completing the initial vocational qualification is good. The most common grade awarded for both competence demonstrations and common units was ‘good’ (4). The proportion of satisfactory grades (1–2) awarded was higher for common units (26%) than for vocational units (9%).
The most notable strengths of Vocational and Further Vocational Qualification in Agriculture students lie, in particular, in their practical vocational skills and transferable skills. These practical vocational skills are evident in the form of strong competence in the operation and maintenance of agricultural machinery and equipment, skills in animal care and handling and the management of everyday farm tasks. Key strengths in terms of transferable skills include initiative, the ability to work independently, a sense of responsibility, problem-solving skills and a willingness to take on new tasks and learn new things. However, some graduates still have room for improvement in both their practical vocational skills and transferable skills. In both qualifications, the key areas for development relate to entrepreneurial and financial skills as well as digital and technological skills.
Dropping out is quite common in the Vocational and Further Vocational Qualification in Agriculture.
Of the students who started studying for the Vocational Qualification in Agriculture in 2022, 61% had graduated three years later. Of the students who started studying for the Further Vocational Qualification in Agriculture in 2023, just under half had completed the qualification two years later. In both qualifications, just under a fifth of students had dropped out of VET altogether. In the Specialist Vocational Qualification in Agriculture, however, the vast majority of students graduated within two years, and the number of students dropping out was low.
The majority of students were satisfied with the VET that they have received and felt that it improved their preparedness for transitioning to working life and operating in the labour market or pursuing further studies. Just under half of the VET providers consider Vocational and Further Vocational Qualification in Agriculture graduates to be sufficiently prepared to pursue higher education studies. The most notable factors hindering graduates’ preparedness to pursue further studies are special support needs, learning difficulties, inadequate study skills and gaps in mathematics and natural sciences skills.
The employment situation of Vocational Qualification in Agriculture graduates remained fairly stable during the period of 2020–2024. Of those who graduated in 2021, 71% were in full-time employment or working while studying three years after graduation, and 11% were unemployed. According to the VET providers, the most notable factors facilitating employment are work-based learning, practical vocational skills and transferable skills. In the further vocational and specialist vocational qualifications, employment is promoted in particular by students participating in working life during their studies.
The end of the evaluation report presents development recommendations based on the results of the evaluation. These relate to e.g. strengthening the monitoring and guidance of work-based learning and developing cooperation between VET providers and employers in the implementation of competence demonstrations. The recommendations regarding students’ competence place particular emphasis on strengthening entrepreneurial, digital and technological skills, as well as communication skills.