4.4 ESG Standard 2.3 Implementing processes - Institutional quality audit
Standard
External quality assurance processes should be reliable, useful, pre-defined, implemented consistently and published. They include:
- a self-assessment or equivalent
- an external assessment, normally including a site visit
- a report resulting from the external assessment
- consistent follow-up.
Institutional quality audit compliance
The FINEEC audit process aligns with the four stages outlined in the standard. FINEEC conducts quality audits in Finnish, Swedish and English, with the language of the audit agreed upon in the audit agreement between FINEEC and the HEI. The audit manual is available in these three languages and includes information regarding the purpose and the objectives of the audit, the applied principles, the evaluation areas and criteria, a description of the audit process (Chapter 5 in the audit manual) and the potential outcomes of the audit. The manual also includes self-assessment guidelines and a description of the structure of the self-assessment report. By carrying out its audits consistently and transparently, FINEEC ensures that its audits are widely accepted by Finnish HEIs and other stakeholders.
The audit process starts with the HEI registering for the fourth cycle audit with a contact person designated by FINEEC. FINEEC organises a start-up meeting with the HEI to discuss the audit and the agreement is signed at least one year before the planned audit visit. The agreement specifies the schedule, language and the optional strategic cross-cutting theme of the audit. The Higher Education Evaluation Committee appoints the audit team and its chairperson based on a proposal from the FINEEC audit project manager. Before their appointment, the HEI may comment on any potential conflicts of interest regarding the team members. Once the audit team has been confirmed, FINEEC trains the team regarding their duties and the audit framework and takes a coordinating role in organising the team’s meetings.
The written documentation gathered during the audit process, including the self-assessment produced by the HEI, is complemented by interviews and workshops with different stakeholders during the site visit. The report drafted by the audit team is based on the data collected during the audit process and follows the enhancement-led approach. The audit report is published on FINEEC’s website. The external quality assurance does not end with the report and the decision regarding the audit result as FINEEC implements consistent follow-up activities that complement the process.
The FINEEC audit process is explained in the table below based on the description in Chapter 5 of the audit manual. The current manual is designed for the pilot phase of the fourth audit cycle and will be confirmed once the pilot audits (2) have been carried out.
Areas improved
- The audit reporting has been renewed for the fourth-cycle audits (see Chapter 4.7.).
- The fourth cycle aims to make better use of available data, reflecting feedback received during consultations. The self‑assessment is submitted together with a list of attachments, including summaries of feedback data. In addition, FINEEC staff compile a statistics package using data available on the education administration's reporting portal Vipunen (see Audit Manual Appendix 1).
- The interactive nature of the audit process has been further strengthened. One example is the meeting between the audit team and the HEI’s leadership, which now forms part of the audit team’s training.
- Some HEIs have wished for more follow-up after the audit. Follow-up after the audit is conducted two years after the audit decision (previously three years). Additional follow-up is linked to the Satisfactory assessment (see Chapter 4.6).
- Based on feedback from the third cycle, FINEEC will organise open sessions for audit contact persons, typically quality managers at HEIs. The aim is to ensure that key messages are consistently conveyed across institutions ensuring equal treatment.
- In response to suggestions made at the FINEEC annual quality seminar 2025, a Q&A page for the fourth cycle has been added to FINEEC’s website.
- Given the growing need for clear guidance, FINEEC has developed principles for the responsible use of AI in audits, applicable to HEIs, audit teams and FINEEC staff.
- Following stakeholder feedback and FINEEC’s own experience, the size of the HEI will be taken better into account when determining the number of participants involved in the visit.
- Feedback on benchlearning was mixed from the third audit cycle. While some HEIs found the exercise useful, it was also viewed as somewhat detached from the rest of the audit process and as an activity that institutions already carry out independently. Given these observations, and considering the additional workload it created, FINEEC decided not to continue benchlearning as part of the audit process.
Based on experience from the third cycle, the Quality Label of Excellence process has been integrated into the fourth-cycle audit process instead of being a separate process with its own excellence criteria. (see Chapter 4.7.)
Areas to be improved
- FINEEC is planning to develop the annual audit follow-up process and seminars for HEIs based on HEIs’ wishes. The structure for the presentations and peer feedback in the annual quality seminars has remained the same for many years.
- FINEEC could make better use of HEIs’ follow-up reports in its activities. In the fourth cycle, the Higher Education Evaluation Committee will be engaged in the yearly process and give feedback on the follow-up.
The areas to be improved will be informed by the pilot audits. FINEEC also collects annual feedback from both audited HEIs and audit teams and smaller changes to the process can be made throughout the cycle.
The Bachelor’s Graduate Survey is a national feedback survey for graduating university bachelor’s degree students. AVOP is a national feedback survey for graduating UAS degree students.