4.1 ESG Standard 2.1 Consideration of internal quality assurance - Institutional quality audit
Standard
External quality assurance should address the effectiveness of the internal quality assurance processes described in Part 1 of the ESG.
ENQA Review 2022 – suggestion for further development
FINEEC is encouraged to consider weighing ESG 1.9 more explicitly in its methodology and thus also raising the level of expectations of Finnish HEIs regarding monitoring and review of study programmes.
Institutional quality audit compliance
FINEEC conducts institutional quality audits with the same audit framework applied to universities and universities of applied sciences. The same framework is also available to non-Finnish HEIs commissioning an audit from FINEEC. The FINEEC audit framework is broad and covers the three core functions of HEIs: education, research or research, development and innovation (RDI) activities, artistic activities, and societal engagement.
The fourth cycle audit framework 2025-2030 (see Figure 1) has two evaluation areas:
- Evaluation area I: Strategic management supported by the quality system
- Evaluation area II: Learning supported by teaching and guidance
Evaluation area I assesses the HEI’s quality system and its connection to strategic and knowledge-based management. It also assesses how the HEI analyses and anticipates changes and risks in its operating environment and organisational culture. Evaluation area II assesses how the HEI plans, implements and develops its degree programmes and continuous learning provision to support education that is student-centred, research-based, and connected to the labour market. The criteria for the evaluation areas are described in detail for the level good in the fourth cycle Audit Manual (FINEEC, 2025a).
The HEI may also choose an optional cross-cutting theme for the audit that is central for its profile or strategy, and for which it wishes to receive feedback from the audit team. The theme should concretely highlight the HEI’s profile and its ambitions. The theme is integrated into the HEI’s self-assessment. The cross-cutting strategic theme selected by the HEI does not affect the audit’s outcome.
The FINEEC audit criteria compliance with the ESGs is presented in the table below.
One of the premises of the planning of FINEEC’s fourth cycle framework was to incorporate ESG 2015 in the framework and clarify criteria which needed clarification. The ESGs were also discussed with the international experts that were consulted twice during the planning in spring 2025.
In the ENQA external review conducted in 2021–2022, FINEEC’s third‑cycle audit framework was assessed as fully compliant with ESG 2.1. Nevertheless, the ENQA review panel encouraged FINEEC to give more explicit weight to ESG 1.9 in its methodology, thereby raising Finnish higher education institutions’ expectations regarding the monitoring and periodic review of study programmes. While the periodic review of degree programmes was included in the criteria for the third audit cycle, FINEEC has further clarified and strengthened its expectations regarding the ongoing monitoring and periodic review of degree programmes in line with ESG 1.9. These strengthened expectations are reflected both in FINEEC’s communication on the ENQA review outcomes and in the design and implementation of the fourth-cycle audit framework.
The FINEEC Annual Quality Seminar 2023 focused specifically on the internal and external monitoring and periodic review of study programmes, showcasing good practices from various HEIs. The fourth-cycle audit manual now includes a glossary of key concepts, and the Q&A section on FINEEC’s website (currently only available in Finnish) further clarifies expectations related to periodic programme reviews.
FINEEC requires HEIs to have a system for the periodic review of their degree programmes. Institutions are free to design a review process that best serves their needs, and reviews may be either internal or external. FINEEC, however, requires that the processes include reviewers without affiliations to the programme being reviewed. A self‑assessment conducted by the programme is not sufficient.The entire evaluation framework including audit criteria have been renewed for the fourth cycle. In terms of teaching and learning, the evaluation area 2 criteria is a continuation on the third-cycle evaluation area 1. The framework continues to emphasise student-centred, competence-based, and research-based education, while integrating labour market perspectives.
Areas improved in audits
- The framework places greater emphasis on pedagogy, the consideration of diverse student groups, and internationalisation and the engagement of stakeholders.
- The criteria include an own sub-area for continuous learning.
- There is more focus on knowledge or data-driven management and quality improvement. Efforts have also been made to clarify expectations in specific areas, such as the periodic review of programmes.
- The entire evaluation framework including audit criteria have been renewed for the fourth cycle. In terms of teaching and learning, the evaluation area 2 criteria is a continuation on the third-cycle evaluation area 1. The framework continues to emphasise student-centred, competence-based, and research-based education, while integrating labour market perspectives.
- The framework places greater emphasis on pedagogy, the consideration of diverse student groups, and internationalisation and the engagement of stakeholders.
- The criteria include an own sub-area for continuous learning.
- There is more focus on knowledge or data-driven management and quality improvement. Efforts have also been made to clarify expectations in specific areas, such as the periodic review of programmes.
The areas to be improved will be informed by the pilot audits. FINEEC also collects annual feedback from both audited HEIs and audit teams and smaller changes to the process can be made throughout the cycle.